Canada has long been celebrated as a global leader in immigration, with a system often lauded for its openness, regulation, and emphasis on economic and humanitarian goals. In 2022, foreign-born individuals comprised nearly one-quarter of Canada’s population, a testament to the nation’s reliance on immigration to drive economic growth, address labor shortages, and counter an aging demographic. However, the federal election on April 28, 2025, marked a pivotal shift in Canada’s immigration policy. The Liberal Party, led by Prime Minister Mark Carney, secured a minority government and introduced a more cautious, conservative approach to immigration, aligning with public concerns over housing shortages, strained infrastructure, and social services. This article explores the context, details, and implications of Canada’s new immigration policy, delving into the 2025–2027 Immigration Levels Plan, the political dynamics shaping it, and the broader societal and economic impacts.
Historical Context: Canada’s Immigration Legacy
Canada’s immigration policy has evolved significantly since the late 1980s, when the government began setting long-term targets to address labor shortages and demographic challenges. Under Progressive Conservative Prime Minister Brian Mulroney (1984–1993), annual immigration targets reached 250,000 by the early 1990s, prioritizing skilled workers and refugees to fuel economic recovery and uphold humanitarian commitments. Stephen Harper’s Conservative government (2006–2015) further refined this approach, emphasizing economic immigration and tightening controls on temporary programs, with annual permanent resident (PR) admissions ranging from 247,000 to 281,000.
The Liberal government under Justin Trudeau (2015–2025) initially pursued an ambitious expansion, aiming for 500,000 PRs annually by 2025 to support post-COVID economic recovery. This led to a population surge, with Canada reaching 41 million in April 2024, of which 98% of growth in 2023 was attributed to immigration, including 60% from temporary residents. However, rapid population growth exacerbated housing shortages, healthcare pressures, and public discontent, prompting a policy reversal in late 2024 under Immigration Minister Marc Miller. The 2025–2027 Immigration Levels Plan, announced on October 24, 2024, marked a significant departure, reducing PR targets and introducing controls on temporary residents for the first time.
The 2025–2027 Immigration Levels Plan: A Conservative Shift
The 2025–2027 Immigration Levels Plan, tabled by Minister Marc Miller, reflects a strategic pivot toward controlled, sustainable immigration. Key features include:
- Reduced Permanent Resident Targets: The plan sets PR admissions at 395,000 for 2025, 380,000 for 2026, and 365,000 for 2027, a 21% reduction from the previous 500,000 target for 2025. This translates to less than 1% of Canada’s projected 41.5 million population in 2025, aiming for a marginal population decline of 0.2% in 2025 and 2026, followed by 0.8% growth in 2027.
- Temporary Resident Caps: For the first time, the plan includes targets to reduce temporary residents (international students and temporary foreign workers) to 5% of the population by 2026, down from 7.25% (3.02 million) in January 2025. This involves a projected decline of 874,124 temporary residents between 2025 and 2027, achieved through reduced arrivals and natural outflows as permits expire.
- In-Canada Focus: Over 40% of PR admissions in 2025 (approximately 82,980) will prioritize temporary residents already in Canada, such as students and workers, who are skilled, educated, and integrated. This reduces pressure on housing and social services while leveraging existing talent.
- Economic and Sectoral Priorities: Economic class admissions will increase to 61.7% of total PRs by 2027, focusing on health, trades, and construction to address labor shortages. New measures, announced on March 7, 2025, include a tripartite advisory council to assess construction industry needs, a regularization pathway for out-of-status construction workers, and support for foreign apprentices.
- Francophone Immigration: The plan boosts Francophone PR targets outside Quebec to 8.5% in 2025, 9.5% in 2026, and 10% in 2027, up from 7–8% in prior plans, supporting French-speaking communities. Prime Minister Carney has proposed a further increase to 12% by 2029.
- Humanitarian Commitments: The plan sustains targets for Government-Assisted Refugees (15% of PR admissions) and allocates 21,200 admissions over three years for humanitarian and compassionate grounds, maintaining Canada’s global leadership in refugee resettlement.
These measures aim to balance economic needs with infrastructure capacity, responding to public concerns about affordability and integration. The plan projects continued GDP growth, accelerated GDP per capita growth, improved housing affordability, and lower unemployment rates through 2027.
Political Dynamics: Liberal and Conservative Convergence
The 2025 election highlighted immigration as a contentious issue, with both the Liberal Party, led by Mark Carney, and the Conservative Party, led by Pierre Poilievre, advocating for tighter controls, albeit with nuanced differences.
Liberal Party: A Cautious Adjustment
Under Trudeau, the Liberals faced criticism for “unsustainable” immigration levels that strained housing and services. Carney, elected Liberal leader on March 9, 2025, acknowledged these pressures, stating, “We had much higher levels of foreign workers, students, and new Canadians coming in than we could absorb.” His platform promised to stabilize PR admissions at less than 1% of the population beyond 2027 and reduce temporary residents to 5% by 2027, aligning with the 2025–2027 plan. Carney emphasized data-driven adjustments based on housing supply and public service capacity, alongside a $25 billion housing reform initiative to support integration.
The Liberals also introduced enforcement measures, such as tighter visa rules, faster removals of inadmissible individuals, and increased resources for security screenings, building on policies initiated by Marc Miller in 2024. These include a 35% cut in study permits and visa requirements for Mexican travelers, addressing asylum system integrity and public confidence.
Conservative Party: A Call for Stricter Controls
Pierre Poilievre’s Conservatives capitalized on public frustration, attributing housing and affordability crises to Liberal immigration policies. Poilievre proposed tying immigration levels to homebuilding, healthcare, and job availability, advocating a return to “sustainable” PR levels akin to the Harper era (247,000–281,000 annually). In a February 13, 2025, interview, he suggested a target of approximately 250,000 PRs, a significant reduction from current levels, though he did not clarify whether this would be scaled to Canada’s 2025 population.
The Conservative platform emphasized economic immigration, faster foreign credential recognition, and stricter controls on temporary permits and international students. Poilievre criticized the Temporary Foreign Worker Program (TFWP) as “out of control,” proposing union pre-checks for Labour Market Impact Assessments (LMIAs) and limiting foreign workers to “rare circumstances” like agriculture or small businesses. Additional measures included criminal background checks for student permits and enhanced border security, such as deploying Canadian forces and extending CBSA powers.
Despite rhetorical differences—Poilievre’s attacks on Liberal “radical” and “globalist” policies versus Carney’s measured adjustments—policy proposals show convergence. Both parties support reduced PR targets, temporary resident caps, and economic-focused immigration, reflecting a broader conservative shift driven by public sentiment.
Public Sentiment and Economic Pressures
Public opinion has played a critical role in shaping Canada’s new immigration policy. Polls in 2024 and 2025 indicated growing skepticism about immigration’s impact on housing, affordability, and social services, with immigration ranking among the top 10 voter concerns in the 2025 election. A 2023 housing crisis, coupled with inflation and record population growth, fueled perceptions that immigrants were straining resources, despite evidence suggesting otherwise. Labour economist Mikal Skuterud noted that linking immigration to housing costs is “completely and utterly false,” but public perception has driven policy changes.
Canada’s housing shortage, with a deficit of millions of homes, has been a focal point. The Liberal government’s Solving the Housing Crisis: Canada’s Housing Plan, launched in 2024, aims to unlock new homes through apprenticeship strategies and foreign credential recognition, particularly in construction. The 2025–2027 plan’s focus on construction workers and apprentices aligns with these efforts, addressing labor shortages while capping immigration to ease demand.
Economic data underscores the need for balanced immigration. Canada’s aging population and low birth rate (one of the world’s lowest) create fiscal pressures, with immigration accounting for nearly all labor force growth. In 2022, over 600,000 temporary work permits and 437,000 PRs were granted, with preliminary 2023 data showing 471,000 PRs, the highest ever. However, unchecked temporary resident growth—particularly international students—strained post-secondary institutions and housing markets, prompting 2024 caps on study permits and tightened Post-Graduation Work Permit (PGWP) eligibility.
Implications for Canada’s Future
Economic Impacts
The 2025–2027 plan aims to sustain economic growth while addressing infrastructure constraints. By prioritizing in-Canada transitions and economic immigrants, the government seeks to leverage existing talent without exacerbating housing or service pressures. The focus on health, trades, and construction aligns with labor market needs, particularly in housing development. However, reduced temporary resident inflows could impact sectors reliant on foreign workers, such as agriculture and hospitality, requiring careful management to avoid shortages.
The projected population decline in 2025 and 2026 may improve housing affordability and reduce unemployment, but it risks slowing economic growth if not balanced with productivity gains. Universities Canada warned that restrictive policies could erode Canada’s appeal as an education hub, potentially costing billions in economic contributions from international students, who numbered just under 1 million in 2024.
Social and Cultural Dynamics
Canada’s multicultural identity, shaped by decades of immigration, faces challenges from rising anti-immigrant sentiment. Reports of hate crimes against visible minorities and international students have increased, partly fueled by economic frustrations. The Liberal government’s emphasis on Francophone immigration and regional programs, like the Atlantic Immigration Program, aims to distribute immigration benefits more equitably, strengthening social cohesion. However, sustained public engagement and transparent communication are critical to maintaining trust in the immigration system.
Global Reputation
Canada’s reputation as a top destination for immigrants and refugees may be tested by tighter controls. Competitors like Australia and the UK are ramping up recruitment, and uncertainties in the US could drive talent to Canada. Delays in visa processing or unclear pathways, as noted by Universities Canada, risk deterring skilled workers and students. The government must balance domestic priorities with global competitiveness to retain Canada’s edge.
Political Stability
As a minority government, the Liberals face pressure from opposition parties, particularly the Conservatives and NDP. A Liberal-NDP coalition could push for higher immigration levels with improved processing, while a Conservative-led minority might moderate cuts to secure support. The 2025–2027 plan’s flexibility—through notional targets for 2026 and 2027—allows adjustments based on election outcomes and economic conditions, but political volatility could disrupt implementation.
Challenges and Recommendations
Implementing the 2025–2027 plan faces several challenges:
- Integration Capacity: Provinces and municipalities must align housing, healthcare, and education investments with immigration targets. Quebec, with authority over its economic immigrants, has set a 56,500 PR target for 2025, requiring federal-provincial coordination.
- Temporary Resident Management: Reducing temporary residents by nearly 1 million requires robust enforcement and clear communication to avoid disrupting labor markets or student pathways. The government should streamline transitions to PR status for eligible temporary residents to retain talent.
- Public Confidence: Addressing misinformation about immigration’s economic impact is crucial. The government should publish regular reports on immigration outcomes, emphasizing contributions to GDP, labor force growth, and community diversity.
- Global Competitiveness: To maintain Canada’s appeal, the government should expedite visa processing, clarify PR pathways, and promote Canada’s stability and inclusivity amid global uncertainties.
Recommendations include establishing a permanent advisory council with stakeholders, including provinces, municipalities, and industries, to monitor immigration impacts and adjust targets dynamically. Enhancing settlement services, particularly language instruction and credential recognition, will support integration and economic contributions. Finally, a public education campaign highlighting immigration’s benefits could counter negative narratives and foster social cohesion.
Canada’s new government, under Prime Minister Mark Carney, has struck a more conservative note on immigration, responding to public concerns about housing, infrastructure, and affordability. The 2025–2027 Immigration Levels Plan, with reduced PR targets, temporary resident caps, and a focus on in-Canada transitions and economic priorities, reflects a pragmatic approach to sustainable growth. While aligning with Conservative proposals for tighter controls, the Liberal plan retains Canada’s commitment to diversity, Francophone communities, and humanitarian goals. As Canada navigates economic pressures, social dynamics, and global competition, the success of this policy will depend on effective implementation, stakeholder collaboration, and public trust. By balancing restraint with opportunity, Canada can continue to thrive as a model of managed migration in an increasingly complex world.
About Author
